Atty. Matthew L. Hinkle

Atty. Matthew L. Hinkle

Matthew L. Hinkle was admitted to the Bar in 1996 and is a partner with Coots Henke & Wheeler.

Carmel Carmel 30 yrs experience 30 year
Call (463) 273-3913 Book Appointment

Profile Summary

About Matthew L. Hinkle at a glance

Matthew L. Hinkle is a Member based in Carmel, Indiana, practicing at Coots, Henke & Wheeler Attorneys at Law, P.C.. They have 30+ years of legal experience, licensed to practice since 1996. Their practice focuses on personal injury, employment, zoning, litigation, and civil rights. Educated at Indiana University School of Law, Indianapolis, Indiana (J.D., 1996) and Indiana University (B.A., 1993). Recognitions include BV Distinguished. Serands clients in Carmel, IN and the surrounding metropolitan area.

Verified attorney profile · Updated June 2026

About

  • Matthew L. Hinkle was admitted to the Bar in 1996 and is a partner with Coots Henke & Wheeler
  • He is licensed to practice in the Indiana and U.S
  • District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of Indiana, the U.S
  • Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, and the U.S
  • Supreme Court
  • He received his undergraduate degree from Indiana University and a Doctor of Jurisprudence from Indiana University (summa cum laude)
  • Mr. Hinkle is a member of the Indianapolis, Hamilton County, Indiana State and American Bar Associations
  • He is a member of the Defense Trial Counsel of Indiana, the Indiana Municipal Lawyers Association, and the Defense Research Institute
  • Mr. Hinkle concentrates his practice in litigation in both federal and state courts
  • His litigation practice involves diverse areas of law including civil rights, employment disputes, general tort liability, governmental defense, police liability, premises liability, trucking accidents, real estate and zoning disputes
  • Mr. Hinkle has experience handling employment matters including complex Title VII claims
  • The subject matter of these proceedings has included diverse issues like sexual harassment, race discrimination, wrongful discharge, retaliation claims, wage and hour violations, covenants not to compete, and trade secrets
  • He has defended numerous governmental entities, police departments and police officers in cases involving false arrest and excessive force claims, police action shootings, police pursuits, and jail condition claims
  • Mr. Hinkle represents cities, towns, townships and counties throughout the State of Indiana and works closely with local municipal and government officials to defend their interests
  • He has counseled and provided seminar presentations to public officials, government employees and their insurers to educate them about State and Federal laws and specific legal issues that they may encounter in an effort to prevent disputes from arising
  • In addition to his litigation practice, Mr. Hinkle represents small businesses
  • He also represents individuals with estate planning, real estate and contract matters
  • Mr. Hinkle is committed to the representation of clients, not only in the trial courts, but also through the appellate process
  • He has argued cases before the United States Court of Appeals and the Indiana Supreme Court
  • While the concentration of Mr. Hinkle's practice is defense oriented, Mr. Hinkle recognizes the rights and needs of injured parties
  • Mr. Hinkle finds it rewarding to help individuals who have been injured in auto accidents, work related accidents and other personal injury accidents
  • Mr. Hinkle believes that his experience handling a variety of cases from a defense perspective provides him with a broad perspective that is beneficial when handling personal injury claims

Litigation Percentage

  • 90% of Practice Devoted to Litigation Representative Cases: Kincade v
  • MAC Corporation, Et
  • Al., 773 N.E.2d 909 (Ind
  • Ct
  • App. 2002) City of Crown Point v
  • Misty Woods Properties, LLC, 864 N.E.2d 1069 (Ind
  • Ct
  • App. 2007) Marion v
  • City of Corydon, 559 F.3d 700 (7th Cir. 2009) Kroger Co. v
  • Plonski, 930 N.E.2d 1 (Ind. 2010) Kolozsvari v
  • Hook Super X, N.E.2d 2011 WL 461626 (2011) Honors and Awards: F. Emerson Boyd Trial Advocate Award Indiana Super Lawyer, 2010 Indiana Super Lawyer, 2011 Professional Associations and Memberships: Indianapolis Bar Association Member Hamilton County Bar Association Member Lake County Bar Association Former Member Indiana State Bar Association Member American Bar Association Member Defense Trial Counsel of Indiana Member Defense Research Institute Member Indiana Municipal Lawyers Association Pro Bono Activities: Member, Sertoma Club Member, Knights of Columbus

Practice Areas Explained

Matthew L. Hinkle's Areas of Practice

Each practice area below reflects the types of cases Matthew L. Hinkle handles, with a brief overview of what that area of law covers.

Personal Injury

Personal injury attorneys help accident victims recover compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain & suffering. Most work on contingency — no fee unless you win.

Matthew L. Hinkle is one of 264,852 personal injury attorneys indexed nationally. Browse personal injury attorneys in Indiana →

Employment Law

Employment lawyers represent workers in wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, wage & hour disputes, and severance negotiations.

Matthew L. Hinkle is one of 169,120 employment attorneys indexed nationally. Browse employment attorneys in Indiana →

Land Use & Zoning

Matthew L. Hinkle is one of 40,226 zoning attorneys indexed nationally. Browse zoning attorneys in Indiana →

Civil Litigation

Civil litigation attorneys for breach of contract, business disputes, civil rights, and class action lawsuits.

Matthew L. Hinkle is one of 454,532 litigation attorneys indexed nationally. Browse litigation attorneys in Indiana →

Civil Rights

Civil rights attorneys for discrimination, police misconduct, constitutional rights, and civil liberties cases.

Matthew L. Hinkle is one of 70,245 civil rights attorneys indexed nationally. Browse civil rights attorneys in Indiana →

Jurisdictional Context

Why local counsel matters in Indiana

Practicing law in Indiana. Legal matters in Indiana are governed by state-specific rules of civil and criminal procedure, statutes of limitations, and substantive law. Cases originating in Carmel are typically filed in the local municipal court or the appropriate Indiana state district court, depending on subject matter and amount in controversy. An attorney licensed in Indiana brings working knowledge of local procedural deadlines, judicial practices in this andnue, and the substantive law that applies to cases brought here. Out-of-state attorneys generally cannot represent clients in Indiana courts without local counsel or pro hac vice admission.

Looking for additional Indiana attorneys? Browse all attorneys in Carmel or all attorneys in Indiana.

Frequently Asked

Common questions about Matthew L. Hinkle

Where is Matthew L. Hinkle's law office located?
Matthew L. Hinkle's law practice is located in Carmel, Indiana. The firm is Coots, Henke & Wheeler Attorneys at Law, P.C.. You can contact the office directly through this profile page.
What practice areas does Matthew L. Hinkle handle?
Matthew L. Hinkle focuses on personal injury, employment, zoning, litigation, civil rights. Each practice area listed reflects experience handling cases of that type in Indiana.
How long has Matthew L. Hinkle practiced law?
Matthew L. Hinkle has 30+ years of legal experience and has been licensed since 1996.
Where did Matthew L. Hinkle go to law school?
Matthew L. Hinkle earned their education at (J.D., 1996); (B.A., 1993).
How can I contact Matthew L. Hinkle for a consultation?
You can contact Matthew L. Hinkle directly through this profile page. Click "Ask the Attorney" to submit a question, or "Schedule a Consultation" to book a meeting. Most claimed-profile attorneys respond within one business day.
What awards or recognition has Matthew L. Hinkle received?
Matthew L. Hinkle's notable recognition includes: BV Distinguished.

Education

J.D.
Indiana University School of Law, Indianapolis, Indiana
- 1996
B.A.
Indiana University
- 1993

Awards

BV Distinguished

Reviews

4.3
1 Review
5 0
4 0
3 0
2 0
1 0
These reviews belong to platform users; they do not constitute advertisement or promotion for the attorney. Opinions are published for informational purposes only.

No reviews yet.