Atty. Penny McElhaney

Atty. Penny McElhaney

Penny McElhaney is from a small town in southern Kentucky. Today, with a population of just over 1,700, the town of Burkesville has but a single stoplight, at the intersection of the main routes of access, Highways 90 and 61.

Nashville Nashville 21 yrs experience 21 year
Call (629) 276-1052 Book Appointment

Profile Summary

About Penny McElhaney at a glance

Penny McElhaney is a Chief Executive Officer and Senior Attorney based in Nashville, Tennessee, practicing at Rocky McElhaney Law Firm: Car Accident & Injury Lawyers. They have 21+ years of legal experience, licensed to practice since 2005. Their practice focuses on car accidents, truck accidents, wrongful death, personal injury, and business. Admitted to practice in Tennessee (2005) and Kentucky (2006). Educated at University of Louisville J.D. (—). Serands clients in Nashville, TN and the surrounding metropolitan area.

Verified attorney profile · Updated June 2026

About

  • Penny McElhaney is from a small town in southern Kentucky
  • Today, with a population of just over 1,700, the town of Burkesville has but a single stoplight, at the intersection of the main routes of access, Highways 90 and 61
  • Just a few hundred feet south from there sits an old-fashioned town square with the courthouse in the center
  • The hamlet is largely unblemished by modern growth or economic development
  • Most of her family still lives there where hard work fills the week and family fills the weekend
  • Sunday mornings are for the Lord at Red Bank church and Sunday afternoons are for good food at her grandmother's house
  • From those humble beginnings, Penny dreamed big of making a difference in people’s lives
  • She served her country in the United States Army Reserve where she earned a CDL and drove tractor trailers
  • She became involved in politics, working on several high-profile campaigns
  • Her adventures landed her in Washington D.C. where she worked as a lobbyist for a large, global insurance company, advised two U.S
  • Presidents, dined with Senators and Congressmen, and brokered deals with foreign governments
  • At 25 years old, she was one of the youngest executives in the company’s history
  • Her career path changed when she was asked to lobby for the passage of a bill to remove repetitive motion injuries, like carpal tunnel, as recognized, compensable injuries under workers' compensation law
  • Penny's father had worked for General Motors for years and both of her parents currently worked at Toyota Manufacturing
  • She had seen her mom suffer a repetitive motion injury and wear an arm brace for carpal tunnel syndrome
  • She had firsthand knowledge that carpal tunnel was real and that its effects could be devastating
  • Overwhelmed by the amount of money insurance companies must buy influence and shape public debate to beat good people down, she decided to switch career tracks and go to law school to help people fight back
  • The stars aligned when Rocky McElhaney and Penny met
  • In what can only be described as destiny well over a decade ago, these two hardworking, people-loving hometown lawyers from humble beginnings joined forces and have been changing lives and righting wrongs for injury victims across Tennessee and Southeast ever since
  • In the role of Chief Executive Officer (CEO) at Rocky McElhaney Law Firm, Penny’s uncompromising ethics, generous spirit, and powerful perspective, have been influential in developing RML’s sought after employee culture and leading the firm forward to continuously win the title of Best Places to Work
  • She has been the driving force behind many of the successful community service initiatives at the firm, like: RML’s annual drive for Gallatin Cares Food Pantry, its sponsorship of educational camps and local sports teams, and support of local patrolmen and patrolwomen through special events and luncheons
  • Penny also serves as President of Sumner County CASA, she is a board member of the Hendersonville Area Chamber of commerce, and was recently recognized as one of Sumner County’s Women Impacting the Community
  • At home, Penny is a wonderful and active mama to three adventurous boys – Luke, Jake, and Tate
  • On the farm she has helped the boys raise tadpoles from the pond, kill snakes with baseball bats, chase groundhogs with an ATV, and shoot BB guns
  • Penny is also responsible for the development of a curious, little, curly-haired girl named Isla Quinn - the self-appointed boss of the brood – whom Penny and Rocky are teaching to be strong, bold, and fearless, like her mother
  • In her spare time, Penny still enjoys adventure
  • She loves traveling with her family
  • She SCUBA dives, snow skis, zip lines, hikes, and does Cross Fit whenever she can
  • She fulfilled her dream of jumping out of a perfectly good airplane and convinced Rocky to take the leap first
  • Penny always loved horses and recently brought Titan (named by the boys) to the farm, a retired thoroughbred that is 17 ½ hands
  • She is thrilled to be caring for the horse and learning to ride
  • She is working on becoming an excellent cook
  • However, she never has and never will be any good at ironing clothes

Practice Areas Explained

Penny McElhaney's Areas of Practice

Each practice area below reflects the types of cases Penny McElhaney handles, with a brief overview of what that area of law covers.

Car Accidents

Hurt in a car crash? Car accident lawyers fight insurance companies for fair compensation — free consult, no fee unless you win.

Penny McElhaney is one of 36,807 car accidents attorneys indexed nationally. Browse car accidents attorneys in Tennessee →

Truck Accidents

Penny McElhaney is one of 4,975 truck accidents attorneys indexed nationally. Browse truck accidents attorneys in Tennessee →

Wrongful Death

Penny McElhaney is one of 31,253 wrongful death attorneys indexed nationally. Browse wrongful death attorneys in Tennessee →

Personal Injury

Personal injury attorneys help accident victims recover compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain & suffering. Most work on contingency — no fee unless you win.

Penny McElhaney is one of 264,852 personal injury attorneys indexed nationally. Browse personal injury attorneys in Tennessee →

Business & Corporate Law

Business attorneys advise founders and growing companies on entity formation, contracts, financing, M&A, and dispute resolution.

Penny McElhaney is one of 501,317 business attorneys indexed nationally. Browse business attorneys in Tennessee →

Jurisdictional Context

Why local counsel matters in Tennessee

Practicing law in Tennessee. Legal matters in Tennessee are governed by state-specific rules of civil and criminal procedure, statutes of limitations, and substantive law. Cases originating in Nashville are typically filed in the local municipal court or the appropriate Tennessee state district court, depending on subject matter and amount in controversy. An attorney licensed in Tennessee brings working knowledge of local procedural deadlines, judicial practices in this andnue, and the substantive law that applies to cases brought here. Out-of-state attorneys generally cannot represent clients in Tennessee courts without local counsel or pro hac vice admission.

Looking for additional Tennessee attorneys? Browse all attorneys in Nashville or all attorneys in Tennessee.

Frequently Asked

Common questions about Penny McElhaney

Where is Penny McElhaney's law office located?
Penny McElhaney's law practice is located in Nashville, Tennessee. The firm is Rocky McElhaney Law Firm: Car Accident & Injury Lawyers. You can contact the office directly through this profile page.
What practice areas does Penny McElhaney handle?
Penny McElhaney focuses on car accidents, truck accidents, wrongful death, personal injury, business. Each practice area listed reflects experience handling cases of that type in Tennessee.
How long has Penny McElhaney practiced law?
Penny McElhaney has 21+ years of legal experience and has been licensed since 2005.
Where did Penny McElhaney go to law school?
Penny McElhaney earned their education at (—).
How can I contact Penny McElhaney for a consultation?
You can contact Penny McElhaney directly through this profile page. Click "Ask the Attorney" to submit a question, or "Schedule a Consultation" to book a meeting. Most claimed-profile attorneys respond within one business day.

Education

University of Louisville J.D.
- In Progress

Bar Admissions

Tennessee
Admitted: 2005
Kentucky
Admitted: 2006

Reviews

These reviews belong to platform users; they do not constitute advertisement or promotion for the attorney. Opinions are published for informational purposes only.

No reviews yet.