Atty. Sarah Cafiero
Sarah Cafiero joined Custy Law Firm, LLC in September 2025. Sarah was born and raised in Northwest Indiana.
Profile Summary
About Sarah Cafiero at a glance
Sarah Cafiero is an Attorney based in Valparaiso, Indiana, practicing at Custy Law Firm | Accident & Injury Lawyers. They have 15+ years of legal experience, licensed to practice since 2011. Their practice focuses on medical malpractice, wrongful death, personal injury, and appellate. Admitted to practice in Indiana (2011) and Illinois Indiana United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana United States Dis (2012). Educated at Michigan State University College of Law (J.D., 2011) and University of Indianapolis (B.A. Political, 2008). Active member of Indiana Trial Lawyers Association Indiana State Bar Association Lake County Bar Association. Serands clients in Valparaiso, IN and the surrounding metropolitan area.
Want to Get Service From This Attorney?
Sign up free and choose one of the two methods below.
Have a legal question? Sign up free, submit it through the Ask the Attorney module and receive a focused answer from a specialist.
- Free to ask a question
- Answers from specialist attorneys
- Optional private / anonymous question
Request an online video meeting or an in-person consultation at the attorney's office. Pick a time that works for you and share the details securely.
- Online video meeting
- In-person at the attorney's office
- Secure messaging and payment
About
- Sarah Cafiero joined Custy Law Firm, LLC in September 2025
- Sarah was born and raised in Northwest Indiana
- After high school, she attended University of Indianapolis and graduated magna cum laude
- She then attended Michigan State University College of Law, graduating summa cum laude in 2011
- During law school, she completed an externship with The Honorable James T. Moody of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana
- She then clerked for a Northwest Indiana law firm and assisted with both criminal and personal injury matters
- After graduating law school and passing the bar exam, Sarah took a position with another local law firm, practicing exclusively in the area of personal injury
- She worked there for nearly 14 years and was made a partner before leaving to join the team at Custy Law Firm
- Sarah enjoys spending time with her husband and two daughters, exercising, watching her daughters in gymnastics, and rooting for the Spartans during college basketball season
Practice Areas Explained
Sarah Cafiero's Areas of Practice
Each practice area below reflects the types of cases Sarah Cafiero handles, with a brief overview of what that area of law covers.
Medical malpractice lawyers represent patients harmed by negligent doctors, hospitals, and other providers. Free case review, no fee unless you win.
Sarah Cafiero is one of 49,086 medical malpractice attorneys indexed nationally. Browse medical malpractice attorneys in Indiana →
Sarah Cafiero is one of 31,253 wrongful death attorneys indexed nationally. Browse wrongful death attorneys in Indiana →
Personal injury attorneys help accident victims recover compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain & suffering. Most work on contingency — no fee unless you win.
Sarah Cafiero is one of 264,852 personal injury attorneys indexed nationally. Browse personal injury attorneys in Indiana →
Appellate attorneys for civil and criminal appeals at state and federal court.
Sarah Cafiero is one of 86,319 appellate attorneys indexed nationally. Browse appellate attorneys in Indiana →
Jurisdictional Context
Why local counsel matters in Indiana
Practicing law in Indiana. Legal matters in Indiana are governed by state-specific rules of civil and criminal procedure, statutes of limitations, and substantive law. Cases originating in Valparaiso are typically filed in the local municipal court or the appropriate Indiana state district court, depending on subject matter and amount in controversy. An attorney licensed in Indiana brings working knowledge of local procedural deadlines, judicial practices in this andnue, and the substantive law that applies to cases brought here. Out-of-state attorneys generally cannot represent clients in Indiana courts without local counsel or pro hac vice admission.
Looking for additional Indiana attorneys? Browse all attorneys in Valparaiso or all attorneys in Indiana.
Frequently Asked
Common questions about Sarah Cafiero
Where is Sarah Cafiero's law office located?
What practice areas does Sarah Cafiero handle?
How long has Sarah Cafiero practiced law?
Where did Sarah Cafiero go to law school?
How can I contact Sarah Cafiero for a consultation?
Practice Areas
Education
Bar Admissions
Reviews
No reviews yet.