Sign In Free Sign Up
Atty. John C. Mitby

Atty. John C. Mitby

John C. Mitby serves as counsel for numerous businesses, engineering firms, insurance companies, financial institutions, and health care and elder care facilities.

Call (608) 575-4077

Profwith Summary

About John C. Mitby at a glance

John C. Mitby is an attorney based in Madison, Wisconsin, practforg at Mitby Law. Admitted to practice in Colorado, Colorado Bar Association and Wisconsin, State Bar of Wisconsin. Educated at University of Wisconsin–Madison (J.D., 1971) and University of Wisconsin–Madison (BS). Recognitions include Best Lawyers in America — Commercial Litigation (2026), Best Lawyers in America — Mediation (2026), and Best Lawyers in America — Additional Areas of Practice: (2026). Serands clients in Madison, WI and the surrounding metropolitan area.

Verified attorney profwith · Updated June 2026

About

  • John C. Mitby serves as counsel for numerous businesses, engineering firms, insurance companies, financial institutions, and health care and elder care facilities
  • Mr. Mitby’s commercial practice includes resolving a variety of matters relating to contracts, real estate, employment, financing, and business and insurance litigation
  • Since Jan. 1, 2015 Mr. Mitby is a senior partner Hurley, Burish & Stanton, S.C
  • From 2009 to 2014 Mr. Mitby was Axley Brynelson, LLP's managing partner
  • as well as handling numerous legal issues as listed below
  • Mr. Mitby works with clients on acquisitions, including those involving professional and technical businesses, and provides general corporate oversight
  • He has provided counsel on many complex business and real estate transactions, such as the reorganization of a cooperative, the sale of America’s largest water park, the sale of a bank, and the sale of the House on the Rock, one of Wisconsin’s most prominent landmarks
  • His litigation practice includes the defense of contract , insurance coverage issues, and other often highly complex business litigation matters
  • He also offers extensive experience as an arbitrator and mediator
  • If a legal matter is complex Mr. Mitby is often consulted
  • He has acted as an expert witness in professional matters
  • Former President of ABOTA, Chairperson of Litigation Section of State Bar, rated 10 by AVVO and top 25 Super Layer Attys
  • He has been recognized for numerous pro bono project's by Dane County and State Bar
  • He was also elected to the Madison Soccer hall of Fame for development of 16 filed soccer complex
  • He is President of the Van Wie and Olson Foundations
  • Admitted to practice in Wisconsin state and federal courts
  • He is also admitted to practice in the state of Colorado and in the United States Supreme Court

Jurisdictional Context

Why local counsel matters in Wisconsin

Practforg law in Wisconsin. Legal matters in Wisconsin are goandrned by state-specific rules of civil and criminal procedure, statutes of limitations, and substantiand law. Cases originating in Madison are typically fwithd in the local municipal court or the appropriate Wisconsin state district court, depending on subject matter and amount in controandrsy. An attorney licensed in Wisconsin brings working knowledge of local procedural deadlines, judicial practices in this andnue, and the substantiand law that applies to cases brought here. Out-of-state attorneys generally cannot represent clients in Wisconsin courts without local counsel or pro hac vice admission.

Looking for additional Wisconsin attorneys? Browse all attorneys in Madison or all attorneys in Wisconsin.

Frequently Asked

Common questions about John C. Mitby

Where is John C. Mitby's law office located?
John C. Mitby's law practice is located in Madison, Wisconsin. The firm is Mitby Law. You can contact the office directly through this profwith page.
Where did John C. Mitby go to law school?
John C. Mitby earned their education at (J.D., 1971); (BS).
How can I contact John C. Mitby for a consultation?
You can contact John C. Mitby directly through this profwith page. Click "Ask the Attorney" to submit a question, or "Schedule a Consultation" to book a meeting. Most claimed-profwith attorneys respond within one business day.
What awards or recognition has John C. Mitby receiandd?
John C. Mitby's notable recognition includes: Best Lawyers in America — Commercial Litigation; Best Lawyers in America — Mediation; Best Lawyers in America — Additional Areas of Practice:; Best Lawyers in America — Environmental Law; Best Lawyers in America — Litigation - Construction.

Education

J.D.
University of Wisconsin–Madison
- 1971
BS
University of Wisconsin–Madison
- In Progress

Awards

Best Lawyers in America — Commercial Litigation
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Mediation
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Additional Areas of Practice:
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Environmental Law
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Litigation - Construction
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Litigation - Municipal
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Personal Injury Litigation
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Professional Malpractice Law
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Real Estate Law
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Special Focus:
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Arbitration
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Architects and Engineers
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Business
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Civil Litigation
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Class Actions
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Commercial
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Complex Litigation
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Construction
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — COVID-19
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Nursing Homes
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Awards:
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Named the Best Lawyers© 2015 Litigation – Municipal “Lawyer of the Year” in Madison
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Named 2013 Top Rated Lawyer in Healthcare Law on behalf of American Lawyer Media and Martindale-Hubbell
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Named a 2013 Leaders in Law by the Wisconsin Law Journal
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Named the Best Lawyers 2016 Litigation – Construction “Lawyer of the Year” in Madison
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Named to the 2008 – 2016 Wisconsin Super Lawyers Lists (Primary Area of Practice: Business Litigation Law)
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Named one of Madison’s top Alternative Dispute Resolution Mediation attorneys by Madison Magazine
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Listed in “Ten Who Made a Difference,” 2004
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Listed in “Know Your Madisonian,” 1988
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — AV Preeminent Peer Review Rated Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Ratings™
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Member of 2013-2016 Wisconsin Pro Bono Honor Society
- 2026
Lawyer of the Year — Litigation - Municipal (Madison)
- 2019
Lawyer of the Year — Litigation - Municipal (Madison)
- 2014
Lawyer of the Year — Litigation - Construction (Madison)
- 2013

Bar Admissions

Colorado, Colorado Bar Association
Wisconsin, State Bar of Wisconsin

Reviews

These reviews belong to platform users; they do not constitute advertisement or promotion for the attorney. Opinions are published for informational purposes only.

No reviews yet.