Atty. Susan E. Mack

Atty. Susan E. Mack

What makes the Law Offices of Susan E. Mack, P.A. distinctive?

Ponte Vedra Beach Ponte Vedra Beach 44 yrs experience 44 year
Call (904) 477-6361 Book Appointment

Arbitration & More Attorney · Serving Ponte Vedra Beach, FL · 44+ Years Experience

Profile Summary

About Susan E. Mack at a Glance

Susan E. Mack is a insurance and adr attorney based in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida, practicing at Law Offices of Susan E. Mack PA. They have 44+ years of legal experience, licensed to practice since 1982. Admitted to practice in South Carolina (1982), California (1983), Connecticut (1986), and North Carolina (2005). Educated at Boston College Law School (J.D., 1982) and Dartmouth College (B.A., 1979). Recognitions include Best Lawyers in America — Arbitration (2026), Best Lawyers in America — Insurance Law (2026), and Best Lawyers in America — Litigation - Insurance (2026). Serves clients in Ponte Vedra Beach, FL and the surrounding metropolitan area.

Verified attorney profile · Updated October 2026

About Susan E. Mack

What makes the Law Offices of Susan E. Mack, P.A. distinctive? Ms. Mack replies that these qualities demonstrate how she practices law and conducts alternative dispute resolution (ADR) proceedings:·

  • Tenacity
  • Commitment to Fairness and
  • Focus on Results, rather than Process.

Susan E. Mack is founder and President of her own boutique law firm in Northeast Florida. Following her admission to the Florida Bar in 2015, Ms. Mack joined Adams and Reese LLP, an AmJur 200 firm (2015-2021) and was elected partner. She served as an Ethics Partner and pro bono leader.

A lawyer in active practice for 39 years, Ms. Mack’s career milestones encompass:

  • Successfully negotiating with Lloyd’s, London to collect over $40 million in overdue reinsurance receivables pertaining to asbestos and hazardous waste casualty claims as well as complex property claims.
  • Leading Law and Compliance Departments as the first female General Counsel in both life/health and property/casualty reinsurers.
  • As a corporate counsel, managing multiple arbitrations of up to $250 million each in controversy to dispositive awards in favor of her corporate client.
  • Concluding large-scale asset acquisitions, stock acquisitions and joint ventures.
  • Starting up captive insurers, reinsurers and insurers, in the United States and Bermuda.
  • Structuring complex reinsurance transactions, including treaty and trust drafting and associated negotiations.
  • Preparing cybersecurity assessments and protocols, in anticipation of future possible cybersecurity breaches.
  • Completing corporate compliance and insurance regulatory compliance audits.

ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION PRACTICE A co-founder of the ARIAS-US Arbitration Society and the first female director of this organization dedicated to the resolution of insurance and reinsurance disputes, Ms. Mack has been appointed as a neutral or party-appointed arbitrator in 120 arbitration proceedings. Since 2001, she has continuously maintained her credentials with ARIAS-US as a certified umpire, certified arbitrator and qualified mediator. Ms. Mack is also an American Arbitration Association neutral, appearing on that arbitration society’s Commercial and Healthcare lists. She is listed as an arbitrator on the list of the American Health Lawyers Association.

Ms. Mack boasts C-suite experience as a General Counsel, Chief Compliance Officer, Chief Claims Officer and Chief Contracts Officer of both life/health and property/casualty companies. Importantly, she has served as a business executive in charge of Transamerica Reinsurance’s Accident and Health book of business, primarily consisting of medical stop loss policies. Accordingly, Ms. Mack’s experience qualifies her as a former or retired executive officer of insurance and reinsurance companies.

Her insurer and reinsurer senior leadership includes:

Head Reinsurance Counsel, Aetna Casualty and Surety Insurance Company (property/casualty and life insurance companies) (1990-96)

General Counsel and Claims Vice President,St. Paul Re, Inc. (property/casualty reinsurer) (1996-1998)

SVP and General Counsel, Transamerica Reinsurance (life and health reinsurer) (1998-2006)

SVP, General Counsel and Secretary, The Main Street America Group (property/casualty insurance companies)(2006-2011)

Secretary and General Counsel, Royal Neighbors of America (life fraternal organization) (2013).

SUSAN E. MACK AS A LAWYER TO CORPORATE CLIENTS Many law firms hold themselves out to be “outside general counsel” to their corporate clients, but those experiences pale in comparison to those of lawyers --such as Ms. Mack-- who have served alongside their clients, learned their businesses, and advised them in both good times and bad. When Ms. Mack counsels her corporate clients, she brings a depth of practical experience and financial acumen to resolve their issues. In the insurance and reinsurance industries, Ms. Mack is one of a handful of legal counsel with hands-on experience in both the life/health and property/casualty sectors. Ms. Mack’s national practice centers about counseling clients in the formation, licensure, regulation and purchase and sale of reinsurers, insurers and related entities, including brokers and agents, claim administrators, managing general underwriters, managing general agencies and service providers. Captive insurer formation and captive-related issues are part of Ms. Mack’s focus. Structuring and negotiating reinsurance treaties and trusts remains a significant part of her practice. Ms. Mack has had the privilege of serving as a Chief Claims Officer for both a life/health reinsurer and a property/casualty reinsurer. Accordingly, she has the substantial experience necessary to provide clients with the insights necessary to resolve complex claim controversies. Her insurance regulatory practice centers around resolving issues that hinder insurance entities’ present operations and future success. In addition to insurance and reinsurance, Ms. Mack advises clients in many other industries with respect to corporate governance, corporate compliance, contracting, employment and agency, trade practices, and cybersecurity and data privacy issues.

PRESENTATIONS Ms. Mack has delivered more than 100 presentations on issues ranging from complex property/casualty insurance and reinsurance claims, aggregation, occurrence and allocation to annuity reinsurance and life insurance securitization. Representative speeches include: -What’s Happening in our Legal Practices Due to COVID-19, Association of Corporate Counsel North Florida Video Presentation, September 24, 2020 -COVID-19 & Its Impact on the (Re)Insurance Industry, Intermediaries and Reinsurance Underwriters Association, June 25, 2020 -The Changing Environment of Life Insurance and Reinsurance Arbitrations in 2019, Society of Actuaries Annual Meeting, October 20, 2019 -The Umpire Master Class (Instructor)-ARIAS-US Conferences-October 2, 2019; November 7, 2018 -The Life Reinsurance Partnership- Is It Headed for a Breakup? ARIAs-US Annual Meeting October 3, 2019 -9th Annual Arbitrator Roundtable, Massachusetts Insurance and Reinsurance Association, September 25, 2019 -Disputes within the Dispute: What Are Arbitrators Doing About It? New York City Reinsurance Forum, September 19, 2019 -Robert Strain Seminars on Reinsurance-Occurrence and Allocation in Reinsurance Treaties; Statutes and Regulations Affecting the Property/Casualty Insurance Industry-1992-2009.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS AV Peer Review Rated-Martindale- Hubbell; American Arbitration Association, Commercial Arbitrator and Health Care Arbitrator; ARIAS-US, Certified Umpire and Certified Arbitrator; ARIAS-US, Qualified Mediator American Health Lawyers Association Arbitrator.

COMMUNITY SERVICE AND PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS Maintaining close ties to the Jacksonville corporate counsel community, Ms. Mack is co-founder and past president of the North Florida Chapter of the Association of Corporate Counsel. She is a 2009 graduate of Leadership Jacksonville. She is a member of the Journal of Reinsurance’s insurance advisory board. She serves on the ethics committee of ARIAS-US. While general counsel of the Main Street America Group in Jacksonville from 2006-11, Susan was a member of the Stat

Practice Areas Explained

Susan E. Mack's Areas of Legal Practice

Each practice area below reflects the types of cases Susan E. Mack handles, with a practical overview of what that area of law involves and how it may apply to your situation in Ponte Vedra Beach.

Insurance Law in Ponte Vedra Beach

Insurance attorneys for coverage disputes, bad faith claims, denied claims, and policy disputes.

Susan E. Mack is one of 120,903 insurance attorneys indexed nationally. Browse insurance attorneys in Florida →

Mediation & Arbitration in Ponte Vedra Beach

Mediators and arbitrators for civil, commercial, family, and employment dispute resolution.

Susan E. Mack is one of 73,315 adr attorneys indexed nationally. Browse adr attorneys in Florida →

Jurisdictional Context

Why Local Counsel Matters in Ponte Vedra Beach

Practicing law in Florida. Legal matters in Florida are governed by state-specific rules of civil and criminal procedure, statutes of limitations, and substantive law. Cases originating in Ponte Vedra Beach are typically filed in the local municipal court or the appropriate Florida state district court, depending on subject matter and amount in controversy. An attorney licensed in Florida brings working knowledge of local procedural deadlines, judicial practices in this venue, and the substantive law that applies to cases brought here. Out-of-state attorneys generally cannot represent clients in Florida courts without local counsel or pro hac vice admission.

Ponte Vedra Beach Courts and Legal Process

Choosing a Ponte Vedra Beach-based attorney means your counsel already knows the local docketing timelines, preferred filing formats, and how individual judges typically rule on procedural motions — details that only come from practicing in this jurisdiction day after day. That local familiarity can translate to better strategy, faster filings, and fewer costly surprises.

Looking for additional Florida attorneys? Browse all attorneys in Ponte Vedra Beach or all attorneys in Florida.

Frequently Asked

Common Questions About Susan E. Mack

Where is Susan E. Mack's law office located?
Susan E. Mack's law practice is located in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida. The firm is Law Offices of Susan E. Mack PA. You can contact the office directly through this profile page.
What practice areas does Susan E. Mack handle?
Susan E. Mack focuses on insurance, adr. Each practice area listed reflects experience handling cases of that type in Florida.
How long has Susan E. Mack practiced law?
Susan E. Mack has 44+ years of legal experience and has been licensed since 1982.
Where did Susan E. Mack go to law school?
Susan E. Mack earned their education at (J.D., 1982); (B.A., 1979).
How can I contact Susan E. Mack for a consultation?
You can contact Susan E. Mack directly through this profile page. Click "Ask the Attorney" to submit a question, or "Schedule a Consultation" to book a meeting. Most claimed-profile attorneys respond within one business day.
What awards or recognition has Susan E. Mack received?
Susan E. Mack's notable recognition includes: Best Lawyers in America — Arbitration; Best Lawyers in America — Insurance Law; Best Lawyers in America — Litigation - Insurance; Best Lawyers in America — Awards:; Best Lawyers in America — AV Rated by Martindale Hubbell-2016 to Present.

Professional Profile

Why Clients in Ponte Vedra Beach Choose Susan E. Mack

Selecting an attorney is one of the most consequential decisions you can make when a legal matter arises. Below are the core qualities that distinguish Susan E. Mack's practice in the field of insurance and adr.

Decade-Tested Legal Experience

Susan E. Mack brings 44+ years of hands-on legal practice — enough to have navigated the recurring fact patterns, procedural traps, and negotiation dynamics that shape case outcomes.

Multi-State Bar Admission

Licensed in South Carolina, California, and Connecticut, Susan E. Mack can represent clients in cases that span state lines or require counsel in multiple jurisdictions.

Broad Practice Area Coverage

Covering insurance and adr, Susan E. Mack can address the full spectrum of a client's legal needs without requiring referrals to separate specialists for each issue.

Local Presence in Ponte Vedra Beach

A Ponte Vedra Beach-based practice means Susan E. Mack attends hearings in the same courthouses, knows the local clerks, and understands the unwritten scheduling norms that affect every case filed here.

Search Reference

How People Find Susan E. Mack Online

Prospective clients searching for legal help in Ponte Vedra Beach commonly use a combination of the attorney's name and their specific legal need. The following search terms frequently lead people to this profile and to attorneys like Susan E. Mack.

Susan E. Mack attorney Susan E. Mack lawyer Susan E. Mack Ponte Vedra Beach Susan E. Mack Florida Susan E. Mack reviews Susan E. Mack contact Law Offices of Susan E. Mack PA law firm insurance attorney in Ponte Vedra Beach insurance lawyer Ponte Vedra Beach best insurance attorney Ponte Vedra Beach top rated insurance lawyer near me insurance attorney Florida find a lawyer near me how to hire an attorney

If any of the above matches what you searched for, you've found the right profile. Use the contact options at the top of this page to get in touch with Susan E. Mack directly.

Susan E. Mack's Practice Areas & Specializations

Education & Law School Background

J.D.
Boston College Law School
- 1982
B.A.
Dartmouth College
- 1979

Awards & Professional Honors

Best Lawyers in America — Arbitration
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Insurance Law
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Litigation - Insurance
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — Awards:
- 2026
Best Lawyers in America — AV Rated by Martindale Hubbell-2016 to Present
- 2026

Bar Admissions & Licensed Jurisdictions

South Carolina
Admitted: 1982
California
Admitted: 1983
Connecticut
Admitted: 1986
North Carolina
Admitted: 2005
Florida
Admitted: 2015

Client Reviews & Ratings — Susan E. Mack

These reviews belong to platform users; they do not constitute advertisement or promotion for the attorney. Opinions are published for informational purposes only.

No reviews yet.