Can I claim "unclean hands" as an affirmative defense in my response to an SC-108 filing?

Bankruptcy and Debt 5 views 3 answers
The plaintiff is asking the court to cancel the judgment that he lost against me. However, the fact that he lost is based on his own violations of the law. He sued for breach of contract and property damage and lost because he did not perform the inspection at the end of my tenancy. Because he failed to perform the inspection (which violated the law), the court found that his claims of damage could not be substantiated. I want to use the doctrine of unclean hands on the SC-108 response because I don't think he should be trying to cancel a judgment for breach of contract when he himself performed unethically/illegally. Not only that, the law was applied correctly.

Attorney Answers

3
Frank Chen ·
Yes, but for small claims court, you don't need to get legally technical. Just respond to the SC-108 with the facts and reasons why you believe the court ought to deny the plaintiff's request to vacate the judgment. Legalese is not necessary to get your point across/
0 upvotes
James Michael SlominskiIntellectual Property Law AttorneyLos Angeles, CA ·
While I cannot give you legal advice in this forum, I would suggest concentrating on making sure you properly present all the facts of the entire case in response to the SC-108. And, yes, you can plead unclean hands if you want to.
0 upvotes
Kevin Sullivan ·
You can add unclean hands if it applies
0 upvotes

People Also Asked