Should a criminal defense attorney file a cross complaint?

7 views 8 answers
If a paid defense attorney represents someone and the client requests a cross complaint to be filed and the attorney does nothing and after case is resolved states That's something you have to file. Is that valid?

Attorney Answers

8
Eric Rothstein ·
It is very hard to file a cross complaint after the fact. The police often refuse to take them. In addition, whether to pursue it is a matter of legal strategy and therefore up to the lawyer.
0 upvotes
Jay Finnecy ·
Attorneys don't generally file cross-complaints in criminal cases. Victim's of crime file complaints, not attorneys. Nothing in-valid here.
0 upvotes
George Conway ·
A criminal defense attorney merely advises his or client whether it may be advisable to file a cross complaint.
0 upvotes
Michael Litman ·
The defendant can choose to file a cross complaint, but the police are not usually receptive to it unless it is done at the time of arrest, and both parties are arrested at the same time. Talk to your attorney about it, but it is probably a futile endeavor.
0 upvotes
Richard C. SouthardCriminal Defense AttorneyNew York, NY ·
The attorney can not file the complaint as they are neither the victim nor a witness to the crime. Without firsthand knowledge of the events, they would not be permitted to file a cross complaint based on what you told them happened.
0 upvotes
Nikole Wynn ·
It is the victim of a crime who files a complaint/cross-complaint, not the attorney.
0 upvotes
Luigi Vigliotti ·
A cross-complaint is something that the complaining witness files. The police will not allow your attorney to file that. You, as the witness, must go in and be wiling to sign an affidavit attesting to the allegations. Your attorney is powerless to file a cross-complaint.
0 upvotes