HOW CAN ONE PROVE OWNERSHIP OF A STOLEN ITEM WITH NO RECEIPT.

Q: What does it mean to waive rights to a speedy trial

See the full attorney answers on the linked page.

Q: What will my sentence be for Class B Misdemeanor for theft?

See the full attorney answers on the linked page.

Q: I am On ARD Probation In a State That I Do Not Normally Reside(Only there for college).

See the full attorney answers on the linked page.

Q: HOW DO I GO ABOUT GETTING ANOTHER PUBLIC DEFENDER. HE CAME OUT AND TOLD ME HE DIDNT CARE ABOUT MY CASE.

See the full attorney answers on the linked page.

Q: If my car is being assaulted (with me in it) by thrown cups of liquid/slapped by picketers, to what degree is defense allowed?

See the full attorney answers on the linked page.

Q: Proof of probation completion. Wich documents???

See the full attorney answers on the linked page.

Anonymous May 5, 2014 Criminal Defense 5 views 4 answers

TWO PEOPLE ARE CLAIMING THEY OWN A ITEM. Joe says item was stolen from his home, and Mike is saying he had bought the item on vacation. Both parties have no receipt of ownership. How do they prove who owns the item?

Attorney Answers

Joseph Schultz

Joseph Schultz · Jun 15, 2026

Testimony under oath is evidence of ownership. Therefore, you having conflicting evidence. In a criminal prosecution, the prosecutor must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Conflicting testimony generally makes it harder for them to prove their case. You should contact a local attorney and discuss your case with them. A more detailed account of the evidence is necessary to advise you. Good luck.

0 upvotes

Daniel Myshin

Daniel Myshin · Jun 15, 2026

Mr. Shultz and Mr. De Groot have provided good answers. I add only the possibility that other corroborating evidence is possible. For instance, does either Joe or Mike have a witness who observed them in possession of the item prior to the dispute? What about photographs or statements to others that corroborate their claim of possession? (ie. Hey, Bill, come over and take a look at my new big-screen TV!) It all comes down to which of the two, Joe or Mike, is more credible. Good luck.

0 upvotes

Robert Degroot

Robert Degroot · Jun 15, 2026

What exactly does each one say about the item? Who is more convincing? Testimony is used to prove who owns the item.

0 upvotes

Amy Glass

Amy Glass · Jun 15, 2026

It should also be noted that credibility of each witness will be a huge issue when the court is determining which witness is more likely to be telling the truth. For example, a person's criminal record will be reviewed and brought into court if there is any record of dishonesty (theft, etc.) so if one witness has a shady past, that will come into play during a trial as well.

0 upvotes